Is Facebook ethical?

What Choice found

Choice can get this wrong — tell us if something's off.

1–10 of 47

Privacy & surveillance Allegation Against

Facebook is accused of enabling child sex trafficking on marketplaces

Facebook is accused of allowing child sex trafficking to occur through its marketplaces platform.

5 sourcesRead sources
nmdoj.gov
Court Orders Meta to Pay $942 Million and Overhaul Protections for Children on Facebook and Instagram in Landmark New Mexico Ruling
cnn.com
New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez sued Meta in 2023 for allegedly creating a “breeding ground” for child predators on Facebook and Instagram, claims that the company denies.
courthousenews.com
And while monumental, Wednesday’s verdict pales in comparison to one issued yesterday, when a jury in New Mexico ordered Meta to pay a staggering $375 million to the state for violating consumer protection law by enabling child sexual exploitation on Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp.
nbcnews.com
The state claims Meta told the public Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp are safe for New Mexico teens and children, while hiding the truth about how much dangerous and harmful content the company hosts.
theguardian.com
The investigation was published in April 2023, titled How Facebook and Instagram became marketplaces for child sex trafficking.

Privacy & surveillance Confirmed Against

Facebook sold user data to outside parties

Facebook sold user data to outside parties without full disclosure.

2 sourcesRead sources
finance.yahoo.com
New Mexico argued that Facebook failed to disclose ⁠that it sold user data to outside parties and allowed harmful content to spread when doing so benefited the company's bottom line.
usnews.com
New Mexico argued that Facebook failed to ​disclose that it sold user data to outside parties and allowed harmful content to spread when doing so benefited the company's bottom line.

Corporate conduct Official statement Against

Facebook suppressed an explosive New York Post article detailing how Hunter Biden used the position

Shortly before the 2020 presidential election, Facebook suppressed an explosive New York Post article detailing how Hunter Biden used the position and influence of his father, now- President Biden, for personal gain, with the apparent awareness of President Biden.

1 sourceRead sources
oversight.house.gov
Shortly before the 2020 presidential election, Facebook suppressed an explosive New York Post article detailing how Hunter Biden used the position and influence of his father, now- President Biden, for personal gain, with the apparent awareness of President Biden.

Corporate conduct Confirmed Against

Facebook states photos become inaccessible after account deletion

Facebook stated to users that after account deletion, photos and videos would be inaccessible.

1 sourceRead sources
ftc.gov
• Facebook’s Deception Regarding Photo and Video Deletion: Facebook stated to users that, when they deactivate or delete their accounts, their photos and videos would be inaccessible.

Speech & moderation Allegation You decide

Facebook suppressed the Post article about the Biden family following guidance from the FBI

Facebook’s suppression of the Post article—and allegations of Biden family corruption highly relevant to the 2020 presidential election—following guidance from the FBI is highly troubling.

1 sourceRead sources
oversight.house.gov
Facebook’s suppression of the Post article—and allegations of Biden family corruption highly relevant to the 2020 presidential election—following guidance from the FBI is highly troubling.

Privacy & surveillance Allegation Against

Facebook is accused of selling user data to advertisers

Facebook is accused of selling user data to advertisers, generating $70 billion in revenue in 2019.

1 sourceRead sources
jolt.law.harvard.edu
Indeed, most of Facebook’s revenue is derived from selling ads and user data to advertisers; in 2019 alone, these sales generated $70 billion in revenue for the social media giant.
FTC v. Facebook: Social Media Giant Sued for Anticompetitive Conduct - Harvard Journal of Law & Technology

Workplace equity Allegation Against

Civil rights groups sued Facebook and Instagram for targeting predatory college ads at Black users

Civil Rights Groups Sue Facebook and Instagram For Targeting Predatory College Ads at Black Users.

2 sourcesRead sources
brookings.edu
ERC alleges Facebook and Instagram are public accommodations (i.e., businesses that must serve everyone without discrimination), receiving valuable targeted ads is part of the benefit of the bargain a user makes with Meta, and that by discriminating in ad delivery, Meta is providing different quality service for the same price.
republicreport.org
Civil Rights Groups Sue Facebook and Instagram For Targeting Predatory College Ads at Black Users

Education Confirmed In favor

Facebook plans 100k scholarships for Black students

Facebook plans 100,000 scholarships for Black students on track to attain digital skills certification and launches a new feature called Lift Black Voices.

2 sourcesRead sources
thehill.com
The company additionally plans 100,000 scholarships to black students on track to attain their digital skills certification, as well as the launch of a new Facebook feature entitled Lift Black Voices.
engadget.com
Some of Facebook's other plans to address racial inequality include providing free training to Black and Latinx individuals through a program called Elevate, giving 100,000 scholarships to Black students in its Facebook Blueprint program and donating $5 million to over 250,000 Facebook Fundraisers created for the Equal Justice Initiative, Thurgood Marshall College Fund and the Innocence Project.

Corporate conduct Confirmed Against

Facebook censors The Post's Black Lives Matter reporting

Facebook censors The Post's reporting on Black Lives Matter.

1 sourceRead sources
nypost.com
Exclusive | Facebook still censoring The Post's reporting on Black Lives Matter

Workplace equity Settlement Against

Facebook settles discrimination claims against Black applicants and workers

Facebook settled allegations of a general policy discriminating against Black applicants and workers in hiring, evaluations, promotions, and pay.

3 sourcesRead sources
bbc.com
Facebook has agreed to pay a record $14.5m (£10.1m) to settle claims it discriminated against US workers in its hiring practices.
Facebook settles US worker discrimination claims
"Facebook is not above the law, and must comply with our nation's federal civil rights laws, which prohibit discriminatory recruitment and hiring practices," said Assistant Attorney General Kristen Clarke of the DOJ.
cbsnews.com
MENLO PARK (CBS SF / CNN) -- One current Facebook manager and two job applicants have filed a charge with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission alleging the Menlo Park-based company has "a general policy of discrimination against Black applicants and workers, including in hiring, evaluations, promotions, and pay."
"People of color and Black workers in particular remain underrepresented at all levels of Facebook and especially at the management and leadership levels.
Black Facebook Employee, Job Applicants File EEOC Complaint Alleging Discrimination - CBS San Francisco
cnn.com
“People of color and Black workers in particular remain underrepresented at all levels of Facebook and especially at the management and leadership levels.
One current Facebook manager and two job applicants have filed a charge with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission alleging that Facebook has “a general policy of discrimination against Black applicants and workers, including in hiring, evaluations, promotions, and pay.”
Black Facebook employee and two job applicants file EEOC complaint alleging discrimination | CNN Business