Is Google ethical?

What Choice found

Choice can get this wrong — tell us if something's off.

1–10 of 67

Privacy & surveillance Ruling

Google intercepted, tracked, collected, and sold consumer mobile app browsing history

In the original complaint filed in July 2020, the plaintiffs said that Google "intercepts, tracks, collects and sells consumer mobile app browsing history and activity data regardless of what safeguards or ‘privacy settings’ consumers undertake to protect their privacy.".

8 sourcesRead sources
cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov
Plaintiffs alleged, on behalf of a class of an estimated 247.7 million persons residing in the United States, that Google violated its users’ privacy rights by continuously tracking their location and storing that data even after users had switched off the “Location History” feature on their devices.
fortune.com
The company maintained its stance even though the eight-person jury concluded Google had been spying in violation of California privacy laws.
Even though the jury came up with a far lower calculation for the damages, one of the lawyers who brought the case against Google hailed the outcome as a victory for privacy protection.
jolt.law.harvard.edu
In the previous action, which gave rise to the consent order at issue, the FTC alleged Google had misrepresented its privacy policies to Gmail users when it launched its social networking tool, Google Buzz.
business-humanrights.org
federal jury determined on Wednesday that Alphabet's Google must pay $425 million for invading users' privacy by continuing to collect data for millions of users who had switched off a tracking feature in their Google account.
The verdict comes after a trial in the federal court in San Francisco over allegations that Google over an eight-year period accessed users' mobile devices to collect, save, and use their data, violating privacy assurances under its Web & App Activity setting.
cbsnews.com
Even though the jury came up with a far lower calculation for the damages, one of the lawyers who brought the case against Google hailed the outcome as a victory for privacy protection.
cnbc.com
Google has faced other privacy lawsuits, including one earlier this year where it paid nearly $1.4 billion in a settlement with Texas over allegations the company violated the state's privacy laws.
The jury found Google liable on two of the three claims of privacy violations brought by the plaintiffs.
The verdict comes after a trial in the federal court in San Francisco over allegations that Google over an eight-year period accessed users' mobile devices to collect, save, and use their data, violating privacy assurances under its Web & App Activity setting.
kiplinger.com
In the original complaint filed in July 2020, the plaintiffs said that Google "intercepts, tracks, collects and sells consumer mobile app browsing history and activity data regardless of what safeguards or ‘privacy settings’ consumers undertake to protect their privacy."
In September, a federal jury in California found Google liable on two counts of privacy violations for continuing to collect the data of millions of users who had turned off a data-tracking setting in their Google Accounts.
The jury agreed with the plaintiffs that this constituted an invasion of privacy, though it didn't agree that Google violated users' privacy with malice, oppression or fraud — a distinction that would have, potentially, allowed the court to demand "disgorgement" of the profits Google made by collecting that data.
$425 Million Google Class Action Lawsuit: Do You Qualify for a Payout? | Kiplinger
theguardian.com
The European Consumer Organisation (BEUC) based its complaint on research by the Forbrukerrådet, the Norwegian consumer agency, which claimed Google used “various tricks” to ensure location history and web and app activity were enabled.

Corporate conduct Settlement

Google settles lawsuits alleging chatbot-linked teen suicide

Google settled lawsuits alleging its chatbots contributed to a teen suicide.

1 sourceRead sources
theguardian.com
Google and AI startup to settle lawsuits alleging chatbots led to teen suicide

Privacy & surveillance Allegation

Attorney General Karl Racine sued Google over allegations of constant surveillance

Attorney General Karl Racine sued Google on Monday over allegations that the company uses "constant surveillance" and deploys deceptive methods to gain access to users' location data.

1 sourceRead sources
newsweek.com
Attorney General Karl Racine sued Google on Monday over allegations that the company uses "constant surveillance" and deploys deceptive methods to gain access to users' location data.
The lawsuit states that Google uses "repeated nudging, misleading pressure tactics, and evasive and deceptive descriptions of features and settings," to encourage users to turn on their location services even when it is not necessary to use the app.
Washington D.C. Attorney General Karl Racine sued Google on Monday over allegations that the company uses "constant surveillance" and deploys deceptive methods to gain access to users' location data.
Google Accused Of ‘Constant Surveillance’, Deceptive Methods to Maintain Access to User Data - Newsweek

Workplace equity Ruling

Google subjected male employees to a relentless campaign of hostility

EXCLUSIVE: A senior executive at Google subjected male employees to a "relentless campaign" of hostility and discrimination – systematically targeting men to be fired, denying them promotions, refusing to allow them to contribute in meetings and even distributing memberships to professional organizations that only served women as Christmas gifts -- a bombshell lawsuit alleges.

2 sourcesRead sources
businessinsider.com
A federal jury in New York found Friday that Google retaliated against a female executive when she made a complaint saying that the company had discriminated against her by hiring her at a lower, lesser-paid position than some of her male peers.
Google Loses Gender-Bias Trial, Owes Ulku Rowe $1.15 Million - Business Insider
foxnews.com
EXCLUSIVE: A senior executive at Google subjected male employees to a "relentless campaign" of hostility and discrimination – systematically targeting men to be fired, denying them promotions, refusing to allow them to contribute in meetings and even distributing memberships to professional organizations that only served women as Christmas gifts -- a bombshell lawsuit alleges.
Google exec denied men promotions, favored women: lawsuit | Fox News

Labor & working conditions Allegation

Google is accused of terminating employees for union activity

Google is accused of terminating employees who attempted to organize a union.

1 sourceRead sources
businessinsider.com
Those employees subsequently filed a complaint with the NLRB alleging that Google terminated them for attempting to organize a union.

Corporate conduct Settlement

Google agreed to destroy billions of data records of users' private browsing activities

Google in April 2024 agreed to destroy billions of data records of users' private browsing activities to settle a lawsuit that alleged it tracked people who thought they were browsing privately, including in "Incognito" mode.

2 sourcesRead sources
business-humanrights.org
Google in April 2024 agreed to destroy billions of data records of users' private browsing activities to settle a lawsuit that alleged it tracked people who thought they were browsing privately, including in "Incognito" mode.
cnbc.com
Google in April 2024 agreed to destroy billions of data records of users' private browsing activities to settle a lawsuit that alleged it tracked people who thought they were browsing privately, including in "Incognito" mode.

Corporate conduct Confirmed

Google conceals internal conversations

Google concealed internal conversations for 15 years.

1 sourceRead sources
niemanlab.org
How Google spent 15 years concealing its internal conversations | Nieman Journalism Lab
"How Google spent 15 years concealing its internal conversations." Nieman Journalism Lab.
How Google spent 15 years concealing its internal conversations
title = How Google spent 15 years concealing its internal conversations
How Google spent 15 years concealing its internal conversations.

Corporate conduct Allegation

Google is accused of concealing sexual misconduct allegations

A Google shareholder filed a lawsuit alleging the company concealed sexual misconduct allegations against former executives.

1 sourceRead sources
cnet.com
A Google shareholder has filed a lawsuit against the company’s executive officers and board of directors, alleging the company concealed sexual misconduct allegations against former executives.
Google sued by shareholder alleging sexual misconduct cover-up - CNET

Corporate conduct Confirmed

Google gives $150k in free ads to anti-abortion group

Google provided $150,000 in free advertising to an anti-abortion group that misleads women into believing it offers abortion services.

1 sourceRead sources
independent.co.uk
Google has given $150,000 of free advertising to an anti-abortion group that tricks women into thinking it offers abortion services but actually seeks to stop “abortion-minded women” from having their pregnancies terminated.

Privacy & surveillance Ruling

Google was fined $462 million by Ireland’s Data Protection Commission for violating EU privacy rules related to the collection

Ireland’s Data Protection Commission announced on Monday that it has fined Google 403 million euros, or about $462 million, over the tech giant’s processing of location data.

5 sourcesRead sources
abcnews.com
Google hit with $463 million fine for EU location data rule breach - ABC News
Google has been fined 403 million euros ($463 million) for breaching the European Union's strict privacy rules because it mishandled users' location data, the bloc's data privacy watchdog said Monday.
fortune.com
Google has been fined 403 million euros ($463 million) for breaching the European Union’s strict privacy rules because it mishandled users’ location data, the bloc’s data privacy watchdog said Monday.
Google fined €403 million by EU over location data privacy violations
Google fined €403 million by EU over location data privacy violations | Fortune
bbc.com
Google fined €403m by Irish data watchdog over location tracking
In addition to being fined, Google has also been ordered to bring its data processing into compliance within six months.
Google has been fined €403m (£345m) by the Republic of Ireland's Data Protection Commission (DPC) over its handling of location data.
fastcompany.com
Google fined $462 million after regulators uncover problems with a familiar feature - Fast Company
The commission also ordered that Google bring its processing of location data into compliance within six months.
Ireland’s Data Protection Commission announced on Monday that it has fined Google 403 million euros, or about $462 million, over the tech giant’s processing of location data.
theguardian.com
The fine, imposed by Ireland’s Data Protection Commission (DPC), comes after complaints from multiple European consumer organisations that Google was following every step users took.
Google fined more than €400m by Irish regulator over its use of location data | Google | The Guardian
Imposing a fine of €403m, the DPC ordered Google to bring its processing into compliance with the EU’s general data protection regulation (GDPR) within six months. It is the fourth-largest fine imposed by the Irish regulator, which has EU-wide responsibility for all the US tech giants with EU headquarters in Ireland.
Imposing a fine of €403m, the DPC ordered Google to bring its processing into compliance with the EU’s general data protection regulation (GDPR) within six months.