Is State Farm ethical?

What Choice found

Choice can get this wrong — tell us if something's off.

1–22 of 22

Workplace equity Settlement Against

State Farm settles discrimination claims with hush money

State Farm offered hush money to settle discrimination claims from African-American and other minority employees.

1 sourceRead sources
25newsnow.com
CHICAGO (25 NEWS) - State Farm Insurance offered so-called “hush money” to settle discrimination claims from African-American and other minority employees, according to prominent civil rights attorney Ben Crump, who’s suing the Bloomington-based company on behalf of fired long-time worker.
Civil rights lawyer Crump says State Farm offered cash to settle discrimination complaints

Corporate conduct Allegation Against

State Farm is accused of secretly cutting insurance payouts

Lawsuits accuse State Farm of secretly working to cut insurance payouts.

1 sourceRead sources
npr.org
Lawsuits accuse State Farm of secretly working to cut insurance payouts
According to Drummond, the Oklahoma attorney general, State Farm has "secretly and fraudulently withheld from policyholders" information about coverage restrictions that the insurer applies internally when it assesses claims for hail damage.
Lawsuits accuse State Farm of secretly working to cut insurance payouts for hail damage : NPR

LGBTQ+ policies Confirmed You decide

State Farm to offer benefits to same-sex partners

State Farm plans to offer benefits to same-sex partners.

2 sourcesRead sources
pantagraph.com
State Farm to offer benefits to same-sex partners
huffpost.com
State Farm Insurance announced last Friday that it will begin extending healthcare and other benefits to the same-sex partners of its employees, according to an Associated Press report.

Corporate conduct Confirmed Against

State Farm paid $422,000 to reimburse customers

State Farm paid approximately $422,000 including interest to reimburse affected customers.

1 sourceRead sources
sec.gov
Respondent State Farm shall, within 30 days of the entry of this Order, pay a civil money penalty in the amount of $211,000 to the Securities and Exchange Commission for transfer to the general fund of the United States Treasury, subject to Exchange Act Section 21F(g)(3).
Among other things, in January 2024, State Farm paid approximately $422,000, including interest, to reimburse affected customers.

Workplace equity Confirmed You decide

State Farm supports LGBTQ+ books in schools

State Farm supports a program to place LGBTQ-supportive books in schools, libraries, and community centers.

3 sourcesRead sources
komonews.com
(TND) — Insurance giant State Farm abandoned its new initiative to distribute “LGBTQ+ books” to Florida classrooms, libraries, and community centers following media reports covering the company’s efforts.
rawstory.com
On Monday news broke that State Farm, the insurance giant, had been supporting a program designed to put LGBTQ-supportive books into schools, libraries, and community centers.
thedailybeast.com
Insurance company State Farm has dropped its support for a program providing LGBTQ-theme children’s books to teachers and libraries after a right-wing uproar.

Corporate conduct Confirmed Against

State Farm scraps gender identity project

State Farm scraps its gender identity project following backlash from the 'Like a Creepy Neighbor' campaign.

1 sourceRead sources
foxnews.com
State Farm scraps gender identity project after ‘Like a Creepy Neighbor’ campaign brings awareness | Fox News

Corporate conduct Allegation Against

State Farm is accused of underpaying wind and hail claims

State Farm is accused of underpaying and denying wind and hail claims, profiting $1.4 billion through the scheme.

8 sourcesRead sources
finance.yahoo.com
OKLAHOMA CITY (KFOR) — Documents concealed under a protective order for years are now public, and attorneys say they prove that State Farm was running a scheme that profited $1.4 billion through underpaying and denying wind and hail claims.
kfor.com
News 4 previously reported the lawsuit has become a point of contention between Attorney General Gentner Drummond—whose office is leading its own lawsuit against State Farm—and his opponent Mike Mazzei in the ongoing Republican runoff race for Oklahoma governor.
kfor.com
OKLAHOMA CITY (KFOR) — Documents concealed under a protective order for years are now public, and attorneys say they prove that State Farm was running a scheme that profited $1.4 billion through underpaying and denying wind and hail claims.
nypost.com
Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond sued State Farm in June, accusing it of running a “Denial Enterprise” under the state’s anti-racketeering statute.
popular.info
On June 24, Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond (R) filed a lawsuit against State Farm alleging that the company fraudulently denied or underpaid claims to Oklahoma customers for damages caused by hail and wind.
aol.com
State Farm secretly changed how it evaluated hail and wind roof claims starting in 2020, and internal documents show the move saved the company $1.4 billion in a single year.
aol.com
OKLAHOMA CITY (KFOR) — Documents concealed under a protective order for years are now public, and attorneys say they prove that State Farm was running a scheme that profited $1.4 billion through underpaying and denying wind and hail claims.
npr.org
The epicenter of the hail litigation appears to be Oklahoma, where more than 600 lawsuits were pending against State Farm as of this spring, according to a law firm handling some of the cases.
Lawsuits accuse State Farm of secretly working to cut insurance payouts for hail damage : NPR

Corporate conduct Confirmed Against

State Farm drops thousands from policies

State Farm dropped thousands of households from their policies, forcing them onto California's FAIR plan.

1 sourceRead sources
nypost.com
State Farm notoriously dropped thousands of households from their policies, forcing them onto the California FAIR plan (which some took to calling the “un-FAIR plan”).

Corporate conduct Confirmed Against

State Farm did not disclose fund restrictions

State Farm did not disclose in Form CRS that it limited mutual fund and 529 Plan options to specific classes.

1 sourceRead sources
sec.gov
These proceedings concern State Farm’s failure to comply with Regulation Best Interest (“Regulation BI”) between June 30, 2020 and August 2022 (the “relevant period”) in connection with State Farm’s recommendation that certain of its retail brokerage customers invest in State Farm’s qualified tuition program (the “State Farm 529 Savings Plan”), offered by the Nebraska Educational Savings Plan Trust, Nebraska’s state-sponsored tax-advantaged 529 tuition savings program, and certain mutual fund shares.
During the relevant period, State Farm did not disclose in Form CRS that it had limited its menu of mutual fund shares to Class A and Class P mutual fund shares or that it had limited its menu of 529 Plans to only the State Farm 529 Savings Plan.

Climate & energy Allegation Against

State Farm is accused of unfair claim handling

Los Angeles County alleges State Farm engaged in unfair business practices by mishandling insurance claims from policyholders affected by the January 2025 Eaton and Palisades Fires.

20 sourcesRead sources
apnews.com
(AP) — California is seeking millions of dollars in penalties from State Farm after an investigation found the insurance company was slow to investigate and underpaid claims from the 2025 Los Angeles-area wildfires, regulators announced Monday.
apnews.com
(AP) — California’s top insurance regulator on Thursday launched an investigation into State Farm over the company’s handling of claims from the January Los Angeles-area wildfires.
finance.yahoo.com
State investigation alleges State Farm's wildfire response broke law 400 times
lacounty.gov
Los Angeles County Opens Investigation into State Farm’s Handling of Wildfire Claims – COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES
lacounty.gov
Los Angeles County Sues State Farm for Unfair Business Practices in Handling 2025 Wildfire Claims – COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES
lamag.com
This week, Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara announced that California was pursuing legal action against State Farm, including the possible temporary suspension of its license.
lindseyhorvath.lacounty.gov
LOS ANGELES, CA — Los Angeles County has sued State Farm, alleging unfair business practices in the company’s handling of insurance claims filed by policyholders affected by the January 2025 Eaton and Palisades Fires.
nypost.com
When a 32-year veteran compliance officer cited State Farm for "shoddy" and "shameful" conduct, a State Farm lawyer complained, and the department reportedly stripped her of her caseload and cut her pay.
popular.info
LA County sues State Farm for false advertising, stiffing wildfire victims
ap.org
California insurance regulator launches investigation into State Farm over claims from LA fires | The Associated Press
cbsnews.com
"State Farm has unjustly ignored this group of survivors, leaving them overwhelmed and frustrated," Barger said, noting the county's legal investigation into more than 500 complaints and documents provided by State Farm policyholders.
Los Angeles County files lawsuit against State Farm for allegedly mishandling wildfire survivor claims - CBS Los Angeles
cnn.com
State Farm violated the law in handling of claims after 2025 LA wildfires, California regulator says | CNN
dailynews.com
The group Consumer Watchdog, on Thursday affirmed the county’s investigation into State Farm’s handling of January wildfire claims, calling it “a vital step to protect wildfire victims.” The group said it has received numerous complaints from consumers about insurers, including State Farm, underpaying homeowners or denying claims.
latimes.com
County opens probe into State Farm's handling of wildfire claims - Los Angeles Times
State Farm, the largest home insurer in California, continues to seek approval of a 22% emergency rate hike even as it faces complaints over its handling of insurance claims.
latimes.com
If granted, the inquiry would be a rare critical exam of the insurance department and how it has handled consumer complaints against State Farm and other insurers accused of denying and delaying wildfire claims.
latimes.com
Regulators may seek to suspend State Farm's license, citing widespread mishandling of L.A.
nbclosangeles.com
Los Angeles County attorneys Thursday launched an investigation into State Farm over their handling of insurance claims filed by policyholders affected by January's wildfires following growing complaints from residents about delays, underpayments and denials of legitimate claims.
County Counsel stated that it has formally notified State Farm, the largest insurer in California, that if it is engaging in any unlawful or unfair business practices, the company must immediately stop such conduct and follow state laws.
npr.org
State Farm has also faced lawsuits and government investigations over its handling of major disasters, also sometimes leading to steep settlements.
Lawsuits accuse State Farm of secretly working to cut insurance payouts for hail damage : NPR
ocregister.com
The group Consumer Watchdog, on Thursday affirmed the county’s investigation into State Farm’s handling of January wildfire claims, calling it “a vital step to protect wildfire victims.” The group said it has received numerous complaints from consumers about insurers, including State Farm, underpaying homeowners or denying claims.
usatoday.com
California regulators have taken the first steps to pursue legal action against State Farm, alleging the insurance company mishandled claims filed by survivors of the 2025 Los Angeles wildfires.

Corporate conduct Allegation Against

State Farm acknowledged a number of alleged violations related to inconsistent claim decisions

In its response to regulators, State Farm acknowledged a number of alleged violations, but characterized them as "unintentional oversights" and "file-specific errors" committed by its claim handlers.

1 sourceRead sources
finance.yahoo.com
In its response to regulators, State Farm acknowledged a number of alleged violations, but characterized them as "unintentional oversights" and "file-specific errors" committed by its claim handlers.
State investigation alleges State Farm's wildfire response broke law 400 times

Media & the press Confirmed Against

A court awarded $14.5 million to a roofing contractor who claimed State Farm defamed him

INDIANAPOLIS — The largest defamation verdict in Indiana history — more than $14.5 million awarded to a contractor who claimed State Farm Fire & Casualty ruined his business and reputation — has been upheld by the Indiana Court of Appeals.

1 sourceRead sources
usatoday.com
INDIANAPOLIS — The largest defamation verdict in Indiana history — more than $14.5 million awarded to a contractor who claimed State Farm Fire & Casualty ruined his business and reputation — has been upheld by the Indiana Court of Appeals.

AI & automation Confirmed Against

State Farm announces AI-driven agent contract changes

State Farm announced plans to replace contracts for its 19,000 independent contractor agents, requiring those remaining past 2027 to sign new agreements cutting pay and benefits and mandating AI tool use.

1 sourceRead sources
qz.com
State Farm announced plans to replace existing contracts for its roughly 19,000 independent contractor agents, requiring those who want to remain past 2027 to sign new compensation agreements that cut pay and benefits while mandating the use of AI tools.

Climate & energy Official statement You decide

State Farm held at least $30.9 billion in fossil-fuel-related investments as of 2019

According to California’s Department of Insurance, State Farm held at least $30.9 billion in fossil-fuel-related investments as of 2019—the most of any insurance provider in the United States.17 Given these concerns, we respectfully request that State Firm provide responses to the following requests for information by no later than June 16, 2023: 1.

1 sourceRead sources
budget.senate.gov
According to California’s Department of Insurance, State Farm held at least $30.9 billion in fossil-fuel-related investments as of 2019—the most of any insurance provider in the United States.17 Given these concerns, we respectfully request that State Firm provide responses to the following requests for information by no later than June 16, 2023: 1.

Political spending Confirmed You decide

State Farm gave $417K to 527 organizations

State Farm donated $417,000 to Section 527 organizations including Republican and Democratic groups during 2011-2012.

1 sourceRead sources
rollcall.com
In the 2011-2012 cycle State Farm gave $417,000 to Section 527 organizations, including $140,000 to the Republican State Leadership Committee; $110,000 to the Republican Governors Association; $105,000 to the Democratic Governors Association; $50,000 to the Democratic Attorneys General Association; and $12,000 to the Democratic Leadership Campaign Committee.

Workplace equity Confirmed Against

State Farm retaliated by terminating employee

State Farm retaliated by terminating an employee after they asked questions about their pay.

1 sourceRead sources
dol.gov
Instead of answering the worker’s questions about their pay, Marc Davis State Farm retaliated by terminating their employment.

Privacy & surveillance Ruling Against

Judge finds State Farm violated consumer protection laws

Judge ruled State Farm violated the Fair Credit Reporting Act and Consumer Financial Protection Act by furnishing inaccurate consumer credit information to credit-reporting agencies without proper notice or correction.

2 sourcesRead sources
consumerfinance.gov
As described in the consent order, the Bureau found that State Farm Bank violated the Fair Credit Reporting Act, Regulation V, and the Consumer Financial Protection Act of 2010 by obtaining consumer reports without a permissible purpose; furnishing to credit-reporting agencies (CRAs) information about consumers’ credit that the bank knew or had reasonable cause to believe was inaccurate; failing to promptly update or correct information furnished to CRAs; furnishing information to CRAs without providing notice that the information was disputed by the consumer; and failing to establish and implement reasonable written policies and procedures regarding the accuracy and integrity of information provided to CRAs.
Under the terms of the consent order, State Farm Bank must not violate the Fair Credit Reporting Act or Regulation V and must implement and maintain reasonable written policies, procedures, and processes to address the practices at issue in the consent order and prevent future violations.
consumerfinance.gov
As described in the consent order, the Bureau found that State Farm Bank violated the Fair Credit Reporting Act, Regulation V, and the Consumer Financial Protection Act of 2010 by obtaining consumer reports without a permissible purpose; furnishing to credit-reporting agencies (CRAs) information about consumers’ credit that the bank knew or had reasonable cause to believe was inaccurate; failing to promptly update or correct information furnished to CRAs; furnishing information to CRAs without providing notice that the information was disputed by the consumer; and failing to establish and implement reasonable written policies and procedures regarding the accuracy and integrity of information provided to CRAs.
Under the terms of the consent order, State Farm Bank must not violate the Fair Credit Reporting Act or Regulation V and must implement and maintain reasonable written policies, procedures, and processes to address the practices at issue in the consent order and prevent future violations.

Privacy & surveillance Confirmed Against

State Farm initiates data breach investigation

State Farm initiated an investigation after becoming aware of unauthorized online access to customer accounts.

1 sourceRead sources
dojmt.gov
What Happened Recently, State Farm became aware that an unauthorized online enablement to your accounts on statefarm.com had occurred. We initiated an investigation to determine the extent of the unauthorized activity.

Corporate conduct Allegation Against

State Farm is accused of willful violation of state law

State Farm is accused of willful violation of state law, with a maximum penalty of $4 million if found willful.

1 sourceRead sources
nypost.com
The maximum penalty amount allowed by law would be around $4 million if State Farm is found to be “willful” in violating state law.
LA files lawsuit against State Farm over wildfire insurance claims

Corporate conduct Ruling Against

Cori and Kerri Rigsby sued State Farm Fire

Cori and Kerri Rigsby sued State Farm Fire & Casualty Company under the False Claims Act (“FCA”), alleging that State Farm defrauded the federal government while paying out claims related to the damage caused by Hurricane Katrina.

1 sourceRead sources
law.cornell.edu
At a bellwether trial, the jury found that wind alone had damaged the property at issue and that State Farm submitted a false record that defrauded the government of $250,000.
Cori and Kerri Rigsby sued State Farm Fire & Casualty Company under the False Claims Act (“FCA”), alleging that State Farm defrauded the federal government while paying out claims related to the damage caused by Hurricane Katrina.

Corporate conduct Confirmed Against

State Farm delayed policyholders

State Farm delayed policyholders, underpaid them, and buried them in red tape during their worst moments.

3 sourcesRead sources
apnews.com
“Our investigation found that State Farm delayed, underpaid, and buried policyholders in red tape at the worst moment of their lives.
nypost.com
State Farm buried policyholders in red tape, shuffled them between adjusters, denied smoke damage claims without explanation, and failed to meet basic legal obligations to the people who trusted them.
cnn.com
“Our investigation found that State Farm delayed, underpaid, and buried policyholders in red tape at the worst moment of their lives.

Workplace equity Settlement Against

State Farm settlement over faces discrimination claim

The source excerpt states: “After she was fired, Mandhyan filed a complaint with the Illinois Department of Human Rights, and after a year-long investigation that concluded last October, the investigation determined there was substantial evidence of State Farm harassing and retaliating against her “based on race, including issuing a negative performance evaluation based on race,” then firing her based on the same reason…”.

3 sourcesRead sources
business-humanrights.org
After she was fired, Mandhyan filed a complaint with the Illinois Department of Human Rights, and after a year-long investigation that concluded last October, the investigation determined there was substantial evidence of State Farm harassing and retaliating against her “based on race, including issuing a negative performance evaluation based on race,” then firing her based on the same reason...
USA: State Farm faces second lawsuit for alleged racial discrimination against employee
USA: State Farm faces second lawsuit for alleged racial discrimination against employee - Business and Human Rights Centre
justice.gov
On October 24, 2024, IER entered into a settlement agreement with State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company, to resolve IER’s determination that the company’s corporate office in Richardson, Texas retaliated against the Charging Party in violation of 8 U.S.C.
IER’s investigation determined that State Farm terminated the Charging Party and placed her on a “do not hire” list in retaliation for raising concerns about citizenship status discrimination, namely for opposing State Farm’s rejection of her valid documentation showing her permission to work.
The settlement agreement requires State Farm to pay over $30,000 in lost wages to the Charging Party and a civil penalty to the United States, train its employees, ensure its employment eligibility verification policies prohibit discrimination pursuant to 8 U.S.C.
opn.ca6.uscourts.gov
Citing her complaint, she argues that her allegations of State Farm’s discriminatory conduct span the course of multiple years and that the district court’s imposition of an artificial cut-off date improperly excluded relevant evidence supporting her case.