Is YouTube ethical?

What Choice found

Choice can get this wrong — tell us if something's off.

1–30 of 48

Corporate conduct Confirmed

Google pays $425.7 million for improper snooping

A federal jury ordered Google to pay $425.7 million for improperly snooping on people's smartphones over nearly a decade.

1 sourceRead sources
cbsnews.com
A federal jury has ordered Google to pay $425.7 million for improperly snooping on people's smartphones during a nearly decade-long period of intrusions.

Corporate conduct Settlement

Google settled a federal class action lawsuit alleging it used Android users' paid cellular data without adequate disclosure or consent

Plaintiffs argued that those background transfers consumed cellular data that users paid for through their mobile carriers and primarily benefited Google, raising privacy and consumer protection concerns.

1 sourceRead sources
newsweek.com
Plaintiffs argued that those background transfers consumed cellular data that users paid for through their mobile carriers and primarily benefited Google, raising privacy and consumer protection concerns.
Google Class Action Lawsuit: How to Claim Payout for $135 Million Data Settlement - Newsweek

Corporate conduct Confirmed

Google makes $10.2 million from fake clinic ads

Google made $10.2 million from deceptive advertisements for fake clinics.

1 sourceRead sources
msmagazine.com
A new report by the Center for Countering Digital Hate reveals that Google made $10.2 million over the last two years running deceptive advertisements for these fake clinics.

Corporate conduct Confirmed

Jurors find Instagram and YouTube responsible for suffering

After seven weeks of trial, jurors found Instagram and YouTube responsible for the suffering of a Chico woman who charged the platforms were built to addict young users.

1 sourceRead sources
latimes.com
After a grueling seven weeks of court proceedings and more than 40 hours of tense deliberations across nine days in one of the country’s most closely watched civil trials, jurors handed down a landmark decision in Los Angeles County Superior Court on Wednesday, finding Instagram and YouTube responsible for the suffering of a Chico, Calif., woman who charged the platforms were built to addict young users.

Media & the press Confirmed

Google accused of designing addictive children's products

Google is accused of designing products that addict and harm children.

1 sourceRead sources
latimes.com
“Today, a jury saw the truth and held Meta and Google accountable for designing products that addict and harm children,” said Lexi Hazam, court-appointed co-lead plaintiffs’ counsel in the related federal action.

Privacy & surveillance Settlement

YouTube settles $30 million children's privacy claim

A federal judge granted final approval for a $30 million class action settlement against YouTube after parents claimed the company violated children's privacy by collecting data while they watched videos.

1 sourceRead sources
courthousenews.com
(CN) — A federal judge granted final approval for a $30 million class action settlement against Google on Tuesday, after six years of litigation with parents claiming the tech giant violated children’s privacy by collecting data while they watched YouTube videos.

Corporate conduct Confirmed

Google gives $150k in free ads to anti-abortion group

Google provided $150,000 in free advertising to an anti-abortion group that misleads women into believing it offers abortion services.

1 sourceRead sources
independent.co.uk
Google has given $150,000 of free advertising to an anti-abortion group that tricks women into thinking it offers abortion services but actually seeks to stop “abortion-minded women” from having their pregnancies terminated.

Privacy & surveillance Ruling

Google was fined $462 million by Ireland’s Data Protection Commission for violating EU privacy rules related to the collection

Ireland’s Data Protection Commission announced on Monday that it has fined Google 403 million euros, or about $462 million, over the tech giant’s processing of location data.

4 sourcesRead sources
fortune.com
Google has been fined 403 million euros ($463 million) for breaching the European Union’s strict privacy rules because it mishandled users’ location data, the bloc’s data privacy watchdog said Monday.
Google fined €403 million by EU over location data privacy violations
Google fined €403 million by EU over location data privacy violations | Fortune
bbc.com
Google has been fined €403m (£345m) by the Republic of Ireland's Data Protection Commission (DPC) over its handling of location data.
In addition to being fined, Google has also been ordered to bring its data processing into compliance within six months.
fastcompany.com
Ireland’s Data Protection Commission announced on Monday that it has fined Google 403 million euros, or about $462 million, over the tech giant’s processing of location data.
Google fined $462 million after regulators uncover problems with a familiar feature - Fast Company
The commission also ordered that Google bring its processing of location data into compliance within six months.
theguardian.com
Google fined more than €400m by Irish regulator over its use of location data | Google | The Guardian
Imposing a fine of €403m, the DPC ordered Google to bring its processing into compliance with the EU’s general data protection regulation (GDPR) within six months. It is the fourth-largest fine imposed by the Irish regulator, which has EU-wide responsibility for all the US tech giants with EU headquarters in Ireland.
The fine, imposed by Ireland’s Data Protection Commission (DPC), comes after complaints from multiple European consumer organisations that Google was following every step users took.
Imposing a fine of €403m, the DPC ordered Google to bring its processing into compliance with the EU’s general data protection regulation (GDPR) within six months.

Privacy & surveillance Settlement

Google paid nearly $1.4 billion in a settlement with Texas over allegations the company violated the state's privacy laws

Google has faced other privacy lawsuits, including one earlier this year where it paid nearly $1.4 billion in a settlement with Texas over allegations the company violated the state's privacy laws.

3 sourcesRead sources
business-humanrights.org
Google’s agreement to settle comes nearly a year after Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton secured a $1.4 billion settlement from Meta over the unauthorized use of biometric data from Facebook and Instagram users.
As reported by Cryptopolitan earlier, Google agreed to a $1.375 billion settlement with Texas over allegations it unlawfully tracked users’ facial recognition data, location history, and Chrome Incognito activity.
cnbc.com
Google has faced other privacy lawsuits, including one earlier this year where it paid nearly $1.4 billion in a settlement with Texas over allegations the company violated the state's privacy laws.
consumerreports.org
That case is ongoing, but a similar lawsuit filed against Google resulted in a $1.375 billion settlement in May 2025.

Workplace equity Allegation

YouTube is accused of racial profiling in content algorithms

Content producers filed a federal class action in June 2020 accusing YouTube and its parent Google of using racial profiling in algorithms to censor their video content and limit viewership.

2 sourcesRead sources
courthousenews.com
The content producers filed a federal class action in June 2020 accusing YouTube and its parent Google of using racial profiling in algorithms and artificial intelligence to filter and censor their video content so it reaches fewer viewers, similar to improper censorship of LGBTQ+ content creators the tech giants said was fixed years ago following a 2019 federal lawsuit.
the-independent.com
A group of black YouTube creators filed suit against the company this week, alleging that the platform has been systematically removing their content without explanation.

Workplace equity Settlement

Google LLC will pay more than $3.8M to more than 5,500 employees

Department of Labor has reached a settlement with Google LLC to resolve allegations of systemic compensation and hiring discrimination at the company’s California and Washington State facilities and will pay over $3.8 million to more than 5,500 current employees and job applicants.

8 sourcesRead sources
apnews.com
The 2022 lawsuit claimed that Mountain View, California-based Google viewed Black job candidates “through harmful racial stereotypes” and claimed that hiring managers deemed Black candidates “not ‘Googly’ enough, a plain dog whistle for race discrimination.”
Google said when the settlement was reached that it strongly disagrees with the allegations that it treated anyone improperly and remains “committed to paying, hiring, and leveling all employees consistently.”
April Curley, a former Google employee, had sued the tech giant for racial discrimination, saying it engages in a “pattern and practice” of unfair treatment for its Black workers.
Google settles lawsuit over alleged racial disparities in hiring, pay and promotions | AP News
finance.yahoo.com
Google said when the settlement was reached that it strongly disagrees with the allegations that it treated anyone improperly and remains "committed to paying, hiring, and leveling all employees consistently."
Google settles racial discrimination lawsuit for $50 million
bbc.com
Google agrees to pay $28m in racial bias lawsuit
cnbc.com
A preliminary settlement covering more than 4,000 Google employees in California and New York was filed on Thursday evening in the Oakland, California federal court, and requires a judge's approval.
Google settles Black employees' racial bias lawsuit for $50 million
courthousenews.com
(CN) — A federal judge granted final approval Thursday to a $50 million class action settlement over claims Google discriminated against Black employees.
dol.gov
Google LLC, US Department of Labor settlement resolves alleged pay, hiring discrimination at California, Washington State locations
Google LLC, US Department of Labor settlement resolves alleged pay, hiring discrimination at California, Washington State locations | U.S. Department of Labor
Department of Labor has reached a settlement with Google LLC to resolve allegations of systemic compensation and hiring discrimination at the company’s California and Washington State facilities and will pay over $3.8 million to more than 5,500 current employees and job applicants.
dol.gov
Google LLC, US Department of Labor settlement resolves alleged pay, hiring discrimination at California, Washington State locations
Department of Labor has reached a settlement with Google LLC to resolve allegations of systemic compensation and hiring discrimination at the company’s California and Washington State facilities and will pay over $3.8 million to more than 5,500 current employees and job applicants.
Google LLC, US Department of Labor settlement resolves alleged pay, hiring discrimination at California, Washington State locations | U.S. Department of Labor
usnews.com
Google said when the settlement was reached that it strongly disagrees with the allegations that it treated anyone improperly and remains "committed to paying, hiring, and leveling all employees consistently.”
Google Settles Racial Discrimination Lawsuit for $50 Million

Corporate conduct Confirmed

Google used tricks to enable location history

Google is accused of using various tricks to ensure location history and web activity were enabled.

1 sourceRead sources
theguardian.com
The European Consumer Organisation (BEUC) based its complaint on research by the Forbrukerrådet, the Norwegian consumer agency, which claimed Google used “various tricks” to ensure location history and web and app activity were enabled.

Corporate conduct Settlement

YouTube settles kids' data suit with $30M payout

YouTube settled a kids' data suit with a $30M payout.

1 sourceRead sources
law360.com
Google, YouTube Settle Kids' Data Suit With $30M Payout - Law360

Corporate conduct Allegation

Google is accused of knowingly acquiescing in unauthorized access

Google is accused of knowingly acquiescing in unauthorized access to Ritter's accounts despite being provided notice.

1 sourceRead sources
latimes.com
Google is named as a defendant in the November lawsuit and is accused of “knowingly acquiescing in, failing to remedy, and materially assisting the unauthorized access” into Ritter’s accounts despite being provided notice.
Former Google chief's spying, sex assault lawsuit sent to arbitration - Los Angeles Times

Media & the press Allegation

Google is accused of hallucinating defamatory statements

Google is accused of hallucinating false and defamatory statements about a solar panel installation company in a Minnesota state court lawsuit.

1 sourceRead sources
reason.com
Last year, Google was sued in Minnesota state court by a local solar panel installation company that claimed Google's AI Overviews hallucinated false and defamatory statements about the company (see more here).

Privacy & surveillance Settlement

Google settles privacy lawsuit for $68 million

Google settles Google Assistant privacy lawsuit for $68 million.

1 sourceRead sources
cnbc.com
Google agreed to pay $68 million to settle a lawsuit claiming that ⁠its voice-activated assistant spied inappropriately on smartphone users, violating ‍their privacy.
Google settles Google Assistant privacy lawsuit for $68 million

Privacy & surveillance Settlement

Google settles $30 million privacy claim

A judge approved Google’s $30 million settlement to families over accusations it invaded kids’ privacy on YouTube.

6 sourcesRead sources
consumer.ftc.gov
Does your child love YouTube videos? Did you know that while little Susie was watching her favorite shows, YouTube was collecting data and using it to send her targeted ads? Under a settlement with the FTC, YouTube and its parent company, Google, must pay a record $170 million for violating the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) Rule.
nypost.com
A judge approved Google’s $30 million settlement to families over accusations it invaded kids’ privacy on YouTube.
US Magistrate Judge Susan van Keulen on Tuesday gave the final stamp of approval to the settlement, ending a six-year legal battle in which parents claimed Google violated children’s privacy by collecting data while they watched YouTube videos.
business-humanrights.org
Google hit with $30 million settlement for violating kids’ privacy
Google to pay $30 million to settle a lawsuit claiming it violated children’s privacy on YouTube by collecting personal data without parental consent
courthousenews.com
The families and their children first filed the class action in 2019, claiming that Google violated the privacy of minors by collecting personal information while they watched YouTube videos.
ftc.gov
On September 4, 2019, the FTC hosted a press conference at its headquarters in Washington, DC, to discuss its settlement with Google and YouTube over allegations by the FTC and the New York Attorney General that the YouTube video sharing service illegally collected personal information from children without their parents’ consent.
ftc.gov
Case 1:19-cv-02642 Document 1 Filed 09/04/19 Page 1 of 19 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION, and PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, by LETITIA JAMES, Attorney General of the State of New York, Plaintiffs, vs. GOOGLE LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, and YOUTUBE, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, Defendants.
COMPLAINT FOR

Privacy & surveillance Settlement

Google settles $30 million privacy claim

A judge approved Google's $30 million settlement to families accused of invading kids' privacy on YouTube.

1 sourceRead sources
nypost.com
A judge approved Google’s $30 million settlement to families over accusations it invaded kids’ privacy on YouTube – and people eligible to benefit from the class-action suit need to file by Jan. 21 to claim their award.

Privacy & surveillance Settlement

Google settles for €403M GDPR fine

Google settles for €403 million fine by Ireland's data watchdog over GDPR violations.

1 sourceRead sources
bbc.com
Google hit with €403m fine by Irish data watchdog over GDPR violations
Google agrees to pay $28m in racial bias lawsuit

Workplace equity Settlement

Google settles $5 million auto-renewal claim

Google settled a claim that it automatically renewed Google Play subscriptions without properly notifying customers, violating California's Automatic Renewal law.

1 sourceRead sources
cnbc.com
Millions of Google users could soon receive part of a $5 million class-action settlement alleging the company automatically renewed Google Play subscriptions without properly notifying customers, a violation of California's Automatic Renewal law.

Corporate conduct Confirmed

Google abuses market dominance in search

Google is accused of abusing its market dominance in general search by favouring its own comparison shopping service over competitors.

1 sourceRead sources
ec.europa.eu
Antitrust: General Court confirms the Commission Google Search case Today, the General Court confirmed the Commission's June 2017 decision that Google abused its market dominance in general search by treating its own comparison shopping service more favourably than competing comparison shopping services.

Corporate conduct Confirmed

FTC investigating YouTube account suspensions

Federal Trade Commission is investigating whether YouTube violated consumer protection laws by suspending user accounts.

2 sourcesRead sources
bloomberg.com
The US Federal Trade Commission has been investigating whether Alphabet Inc.’s YouTube violated consumer protection laws when it suspended the accounts of users, according to people familiar with the probe.
usatoday.com
Federal Trade Commission has been investigating whether Alphabet Inc.’s YouTube violated consumer protection laws when it suspended the accounts of users, according to people familiar with the probe.

Corporate conduct Confirmed

Users reported that Google’s autocomplete feature did not surface predictions related to the attempted assassination of Donald Trump in Butler

In July 2024, users reported that Google’s autocomplete feature did not surface predictions related to the attempted assassination of Donald Trump in Butler, Pennsylvania.

1 sourceRead sources
influencewatch.org
In July 2024, users reported that Google’s autocomplete feature did not surface predictions related to the attempted assassination of Donald Trump in Butler, Pennsylvania.

Privacy & surveillance Allegation

YouTube is accused of violating children's privacy law

YouTube is accused of violating children's privacy law and will pay $170 million.

2 sourcesRead sources
ftc.gov
Google and YouTube Will Pay Record $170 Million for Alleged Violations of Children’s Privacy Law
ftc.gov
Google and YouTube Will Pay Record $170 Million for Alleged Violations of Children’s Privacy Law | Federal Trade Commission
Google and YouTube Will Pay Record $170 Million for Alleged Violations of Children’s Privacy Law

Corporate conduct Confirmed

Google must disclose Choice Screen details

Google is required to disclose each Choice Screen, its distribution agreement if relevant, and implementation plan to plaintiffs and the TC at least 60 days before display.

1 sourceRead sources
coag.gov
Choice Screens: Google must disclose each Choice Screen, the related distribution agreement, if relevant, and its plan for implementing that Choice Screen to Plaintiffs and the TC at least sixty (60) days in advance of the Choice Screen being displayed to any user.

Privacy & surveillance Confirmed

Google collects data for targeted advertising

Google collects data to be used for targeted advertising purposes.

1 sourceRead sources
ec.europa.eu
Google collects data to be used for targeted advertising purposes, it sells advertising space and also acts as an online advertising intermediary.

Corporate conduct Ruling

Google was fined €2.4 billion by the European Commission in 2017 for actions that infringed European competition law

In 2017, 2018, and 2019, the European Commission (EC) announced decisions that certain actions taken by Google infringed European competition law and imposed fines of €2.4 billion ($2.7 billion as of June 27, 2017), €4.3 billion ($5.1 billion as of June 30, 2018), and €1.5 billion ($1.7 billion as of March 20, 2019), respectively.

1 sourceRead sources
sec.gov
•AdSense for Search: In March 2019, the EC announced its decision that certain provisions in Google's agreements with AdSense for Search partners infringed European antitrust laws, imposed a fine of €1.5 billion, and directed actions related to AdSense for Search partners' agreements, which we implemented prior to the decision. In 2019, we recognized a charge of $1.7 billion for the fine and appealed the EC decision. In September 2024, the General Court overturned the EC decision and annulled the €1.5 billion fine. The EC has appealed the General Court's decision with the European Court of Justice.
In 2017, 2018, and 2019, the European Commission (EC) announced decisions that certain actions taken by Google infringed European competition law and imposed fines of €2.4 billion ($2.7 billion as of June 27, 2017), €4.3 billion ($5.1 billion as of June 30, 2018), and €1.5 billion ($1.7 billion as of March 20, 2019), respectively.
•Android: In July 2018, the EC announced its decision that certain provisions in Google’s Android-related distribution agreements infringed European antitrust laws, imposed a €4.3 billion fine, and directed the termination of the conduct at issue. We appealed the EC decision and implemented changes to certain of our Android distribution practices. In September 2022, the General Court affirmed the EC decision but reduced the fine from €4.3 billion to €4.1 billion. We subsequently appealed the General Court's affirmation of the EC decision with the European Court of Justice, which remains pending. In 2018, we recognized a charge of $5.1 billion for the fine, which we reduced by $217 million in 2022.

Labor & working conditions Allegation

Google is accused of retaliating against employees

A group of former Google employees alleges the company retaliated against them after participating in a protest against its work with the Israeli government.

4 sourcesRead sources
finance.yahoo.com
A group of former Google employees may proceed with claims that the company unlawfully retaliated against them following their participation in a protest against the company's work with the Israeli government, a federal judge held Thursday.
Pro-Palestinian protesters’ retaliation lawsuit against Google may proceed
reason.com
As to Google's first point, the Complaint explicitly alleges that the protest was an effort to oppose not only Project Nimbus, but also the "harassment, intimidation, bullying, silencing, and censorship of Palestinian, Arab, and Muslim Googlers." And while the Complaint does not plausibly allege that Skaf was treated differently on account of her race or ethnicity, as opposed to her political views, it does plausibly allege that she and her fellow protestors "possessed a good faith, reasonable belief that the employer's conduct qualified as an unlawful employment practice" under Title VII and the NYCHRL.
cnn.com
“We must resist Google’s repression of worker organizing, and demand that Google be held responsible for their retaliatory actions against employees asking for ethical applications of their labor,” Zelda Montes, a former Google software engineer who was fired for participating in the protest, said in a statement.
jns.org
Google said at the time that employees who were terminated had physically disrupted workplaces and blocked colleagues from accessing company facilities, conduct it said violated company policies.
Judge allows retaliation claims in ex-Google employee’s lawsuit over Israel protest - Israel & Jewish News - JNS

Corporate conduct Confirmed

Google notifies user of doxing in email

Google notified Skaf via email that her details were included in a Daily Wire press article due to doxing.

1 sourceRead sources
reason.com
On March 8, 2024, Skaf received an email from Google Security notifying her that she had been "doxxed" by having her name, work location, and internal Google profile picture included in a Daily Wire press article.

Privacy & surveillance Allegation

Google is accused of accessing mobile device data

Google is accused of unlawfully accessing class action members' mobile devices to collect data on their non-Google app activity.

2 sourcesRead sources
courthousenews.com
The jury, however, did not find Google violated the California Comprehensive Computer Data Access and Fraud Act, and declined to award additional damages.
kiplinger.com
According to the class action lawsuit website for the case, "Google unlawfully accessed their [class action members’] mobile devices to collect, save, and use the data concerning their activity on non-Google apps that have incorporated certain Google software code into the apps."
$425 Million Google Class Action Lawsuit: Do You Qualify for a Payout? | Kiplinger