Is YouTube ethical?

What Choice found

Choice can get this wrong — tell us if something's off.

1–20 of 20

Speech & moderation Confirmed

YouTube bans Trump accounts post-Jan. 6

YouTube banned Donald Trump's accounts following the Jan. 6 Capitol assault under its policy.

1 sourceRead sources
usatoday.com
YouTube also removed health-related content over vaccines and Covid-19 it deemed violated its misinformation policies.
YouTube and other social media platforms banned the accounts of Donald Trump and other political figures in the aftermath of the Jan. 6, 2021 assault on the U.S. Capitol.

Speech & moderation Confirmed

YouTube changes moderation to allow harmful content

YouTube changed its moderation policies to allow more content violating its rules to remain online.

1 sourceRead sources
cbc.ca
YouTube, the world's largest video platform, with 20 million videos uploaded each day, appears to have changed its moderation policies to allow more content that violates its own rules to remain online.
YouTube, the world's largest video platform, appears to have changed its moderation policies to allow more content that violates its own rules to remain online.
YouTube quietly changed its moderation policies late last year, according to a recent report from The New York Times, allowing more content that violates its own guidelines to remain on the world's most popular video platform.

Israel & Palestine Confirmed

Google fires employee for pro-Palestinian speech

Google fired an employee after he made pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel declarations during a conference in New York City.

1 sourceRead sources
timesofisrael.com
In March, Google fired an employee after he interrupted a speech by the tech firm’s managing director in Israel with pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel declarations during a conference in New York City.

Israel & Palestine Allegation

Google is accused of firing 50 employees for pro-Palestinian activism

Google is accused of firing over 50 employees in April 2024 for participating in a pro-Palestinian day of action on two campuses.

1 sourceRead sources
courthousenews.com
Former Google employees are suing the corporation after it fired over 50 in April 2024 for participating in a simultaneous “day of action” for Palestine on two of its campuses, which the protesters argue is protected behavior under multiple state laws.

LGBTQ+ policies Confirmed

Google begins covering LGBTQ+ domestic partner tax cost

Google will start covering the tax cost gay and lesbian employees pay when partners receive domestic partner health benefits.

1 sourceRead sources
nytimes.com
On Thursday, Google is going to begin covering a cost that gay and lesbian employees must pay when their partners receive domestic partner health benefits, largely to compensate them for an extra tax that heterosexual married couples do not pay.

Israel & Palestine Confirmed

Google donates $8 million to Israel Gaza relief

Google donates $8 million to Israel and Gaza relief efforts.

2 sourcesRead sources
tech.yahoo.com
Google has also donated millions of dollars to Israeli emergency efforts, as well as to humanitarian relief support provided in Gaza.
ynetnews.com
Google to donate $8 million to Israel, Gaza relief efforts

Israel & Palestine Confirmed

Google matches donations to Israeli soldier and settlement charities

Google matches donations to charities supporting Israeli soldiers and illegal settlements.

2 sourcesRead sources
business-humanrights.org
"Google matches donations to charities supporting Israeli soldiers and illegal settlements", 4 December 2024
business-humanrights.org
"Google matches donations to charities supporting Israeli soldiers and illegal settlements", 4 December 2024

Ukraine & Russia Confirmed

Google donates $5 million to Ukraine relief

Google.org and employees contributed $5 million through a matching campaign and $5 million in grants for Ukraine aid.

1 sourceRead sources
zdnet.com
The tech giant said Google.org and Google employees are contributing $15 million in donations to aid relief efforts in Ukraine, with $5 million coming from the company’s employee matching campaign and another $5 million coming from grants.
Google donating $15 million to Ukraine relief efforts, blocking RT YouTube channels in Europe - ZDNET

Workplace equity Settlement

YouTube and Google parent Alphabet committed $310 million over ten years to diversity

YouTube and Google parent Alphabet has committed $310 million over ten years to diversity and inclusion initiatives to settle a shareholder lawsuit stemming from allegations the company concealed payouts to top male executives accused of sexual harassment.

2 sourcesRead sources
deadline.com
YouTube and Google parent Alphabet has committed $310 million over ten years to diversity and inclusion initiatives to settle a shareholder lawsuit stemming from allegations the company concealed payouts to top male executives accused of sexual harassment.
yahoo.com
YouTube and Google parent Alphabet has committed $310 million over ten years to diversity and inclusion initiatives to settle a shareholder lawsuit stemming from allegations the company concealed payouts to top male executives accused of sexual harassment.

Workplace equity Confirmed

Google cuts staffers and downsizes DEI programs

Google cut staffers and downsized DEI programs.

1 sourceRead sources
cnbc.com
Google and Meta made cuts to DEI programs in 2023: Here's what you need to know
In line with this broader trend, both Google and Meta have cut staffers and downsized programs that fell under DEI investment.
In addition to cutting staff who worked on DEI programs and ERGs, both Meta and Google cut planned learning and development training for underrepresented talent, according to multiple sources who asked not to be named due to fear of retaliation.

Speech & moderation Allegation

Google is accused of removing content after Russia and China requests

Google is accused of removing YouTube content following government requests from Russia and China, including videos of anti-state protesters and criticism of politicians.

1 sourceRead sources
theguardian.com
After requests from the governments of Russia and China, Google has removed content such as YouTube videos of anti-state protesters or content that criticises and alleges corruption among their politicians.

Wages & economic policy Confirmed

Google spends more than $2 million on lobbying

Google has spent more than $2 million since January 2023 lobbying the California legislature, Newsom's office, and other regulators.

1 sourceRead sources
levernews.com
Google has spent more than $2.7 million since January 2023 lobbying Congress on the federal journalism bill and other matters, disclosures show.
Google has spent more than $2 million since January 2023 lobbying the California legislature, Newsom’s office, and other regulators against the bills and other issues, lobbying disclosures show.

Media & the press Confirmed

Google announces $300 million for journalism

Google announced a $300 million program to support mainstream news organizations and journalism programs.

1 sourceRead sources
cjr.org
In March, Google announced with much fanfare the launch of the Google News Initiative, a $300 million program aimed at “building a strong future for journalism,” as the company put it.

Media & the press Confirmed

Google makes bad move supporting propaganda outlet

Google analyst Gabor Polyak says supporting a propaganda-spreading outlet would be a bad move.

1 sourceRead sources
rappler.com
Independent journalists’ organization MediaPowerMonitor last week published online a piece calling into question Google decision to issue a grant of up to 50,000 euros ($56,000) to New Wave Media, which it depicted as a “one of the staunchest supporters of the corrupt regime led by the far-right Prime Minister Viktor Orban.”
Supporting a propaganda-spreading media outlet would have been a bad move by Google, according to Gabor Polyak, a Budapest-based analyst with the Mertek media watchdog.

Media & the press Confirmed

Google invests in California news organizations

Google investing directly in California’s news organizations that produce original, fact-based journalism.

1 sourceRead sources
gov.ca.gov
California’s local newsroom grants are supported through the California Civic Media Program, a public-private partnership with Google investing directly in California’s news organizations that produce original, fact-based journalism.

Speech & moderation Confirmed

YouTube enforcing hate speech policies

YouTube is enforcing its hate speech policies.

1 sourceRead sources
arstechnica.com
“In fact, YouTube appears to just be enforcing their policies against hate speech, which is what they say they’re doing.”

Political spending Confirmed

Google donates $1 million to Trump inauguration fund

4 sourcesRead sources
finance.yahoo.com
Google has donated $1 million to President-elect Donald Trump's inauguration fund, making it the latest major tech company to chip in.
With the donation, Google joins a number of other tech giants to pitch in $1 million to Trump's inauguration.
Google Donates $1 Million to Trump Inauguration, Joining Other Tech Giants
The post Google Donates $1 Million to Trump Inauguration, Joining Other Tech Giants appeared first on TheWrap.
thehill.com
Google and Boeing have each given $1 million to President-elect Trump’s inaugural committee, joining a growing list of major corporations supporting the Jan.
thewrap.com
With the donation, Google joins a number of other tech giants to pitch in $1 million to Trump’s inauguration.
Google Donates $1 Million to Trump Inauguration Fund
Google has donated $1 million to President-elect Donald Trump’s inauguration fund, making it the latest major tech company to chip in.
washingtonpost.com
Google donates $1 million to Trump’s inaugural committee - The Washington Post

Climate & energy Confirmed

Google stops buying carbon credits

Google says it's no longer buying carbon credits that purport to prevent emissions.

1 sourceRead sources
technologyreview.com
Google says that it’s no longer buying carbon credits that purport to prevent emissions.

Workplace equity Confirmed

Google drops diversity initiatives

Google dropped its diversity initiatives following the president's DEI-killing executive order.

4 sourcesRead sources
business-humanrights.org
Alphabet's (GOOGL.O), opens new tab Google is scrapping its goal to hire more employees from underrepresented groups and is reviewing some of its diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) initiatives, joining a slew of U.S. businesses scaling back diversity initiatives.
cbsnews.com
Google's move notably came in the wake of an executive order aimed, in part, at pressuring government contractors to end DEI initiatives.
them.us
Google, a federal contractor, was one of several companies that dropped its diversity initiatives following the president’s DEI-killing executive order.
wired.com
Meta and Google also significantly reduced funding for DEI initiatives, such as events, training, and recruiting drives aimed at improving representation of minority groups, according to company announcements and employees.

Climate & energy Confirmed

Google deletes net-zero pledge from website

Google removes its net-zero pledge from its sustainability website.

1 sourceRead sources
nationalobserver.com
Google deletes net-zero pledge from sustainability website | Canada's National Observer: Climate News