Is Instacart ethical?

What Choice found

Choice can get this wrong — tell us if something's off.

1–4 of 4

Corporate conduct Allegation Against

Instacart is accused of upselling during direct membership enrollment

Instacart is accused of showing upsell screens to consumers enrolling directly in Instacart+ without a free trial promotion.

2 sourcesRead sources
ftc.gov
When consumers enroll directly in an Instacart+ membership without a free trial promotion, they typically see upsell screens that are similar to those used for free trials.
COMPLAINT FOR
ftc.gov
When consumers enroll directly in an Instacart+ membership without a free trial promotion, they typically see upsell screens that are similar to those used for free trials.

Corporate conduct Settlement Against

Instacart settles for $60 million over deception claims

Instacart pays $60 million to settle FTC claims it deceived shoppers.

3 sourcesRead sources
bloomberg.com
Grocery delivery firm Instacart will pay $60 million to refund consumers who were deceived into enrolling in the company’s subscription service, Instacart+, the US Federal Trade Commission said.
Instacart to Pay $60 Million to Settle FTC Consumer Protection Case - Bloomberg
usatoday.com
Instacart has agreed to pay consumers $60 million to settle a Federal Trade Commission lawsuit claiming the company engaged in deceptive tactics.
As part of the settlement, Instacart will pay customers refunds if they were charged for Instacart+ without their informed consent.
Instacart to refund $60 million to consumers to settle FTC lawsuit
yahoo.com
Instacart to pay $60 million to settle FTC claims it deceived shoppers

Corporate conduct Confirmed Against

Instacart faces NY AG investigation

Instacart is under investigation by the New York Attorney General for alleged hidden AI pricing tactics.

1 sourceRead sources
advocacy.consumerreports.org
“We welcome the New York Attorney General’s investigation into Instacart’s hidden AI pricing tactics,” said Justin Brookman, director of marketplace policy at Consumer Reports.

Corporate conduct Allegation Against

Instacart is accused of inadequate disclosures

Instacart is accused of providing inadequate disclosures on its website that fail to correct the false impression consumers can receive a full refund.

2 sourcesRead sources
ftc.gov
These disclosures on Instacart’s website are inadequate to cure the false impression that consumers can get a full refund if that is necessary to make them 100% satisfied with their order.
COMPLAINT FOR
ftc.gov
These disclosures on Instacart’s website are inadequate to cure the false impression that consumers can get a full refund if that is necessary to make them 100% satisfied with their order.

People connected to Instacart