Is Patagonia ethical?

What Choice found

Choice can get this wrong — tell us if something's off.

1–16 of 16

Privacy & surveillance Confirmed Against

Patagonia breaches exposing customer bank details

Patagonia breached its Australian website, potentially exposing hundreds of customers' bank details to hackers.

1 sourceRead sources
abc.net.au
Hundreds of customers of outdoor clothing company Patagonia may have had their bank details stolen after hackers breached its Australian website.

Community investment Confirmed In favor

Patagonia owners gave away full company stake

Patagonia's owners gave away their full stake in the company to fight climate change.

1 sourceRead sources
supremecourt.gov
Patagonia, whose owners just gave away their full stake in the company to fight climate change, is “in business to save our home planet.”

Community investment Confirmed In favor

Patagonia donates 1% of revenue to environmental causes

Patagonia donates 1% of its annual revenue to environmental causes.

4 sourcesRead sources
observer.com
The majority of Patagonia is now owned by the nonprofit Holdfast Collective, which will give $100 million annually to combat climate change.
fastcompany.com
Over the years, Patagonia has evolved significantly since its founding by Yvon Chouinard. Two years ago, the company transferred ownership to the Patagonia Purpose Trust and the Holdfast Collective, marking a pivotal moment in its history.
fastcompany.com
In a new report that looks at the company’s impact over its 52-year history, Patagonia shares how the change has amplified its environmental work.
Since the company restructured in late 2022, Patagonia has given $180 million to the Holdfast Collective, a group of five nonprofit trusts that the company created to fund environmental work.
vcstar.com
In addition to the Holdfast Collective's work, Patagonia donates 1% of its annual revenue to environmental causes.
After reinvesting some of its profits back into the company, Patagonia gives everything else to the Holdfast Collective to spend on protecting the environment and fighting climate change.

Israel & Palestine Allegation You decide

Patagonia is accused of bullying pro-Palestinian advocacy

Patagonia is accused of bullying and erasing a pro-Palestinian advocate through a lawsuit.

1 sourceRead sources
them.us
Pattie Gonia: Patagonia Is Trying to “Bully” and “Erase” Her With Lawsuit | Them

Reproductive care Confirmed You decide

Patagonia pays for employee travel lodging and food

Patagonia will pay for travel lodging and food for staff on its healthcare plans.

1 sourceRead sources
huffpost.com
Patagonia will pay for travel, lodging, and food for staff on its healthcare plans.

Climate & energy Allegation Against

Patagonia sued Trump over Utah monument cuts

Patagonia sued then-President Donald Trump over his administration's move to shrink two Utah national monuments.

1 sourceRead sources
cnn.com
Patagonia’s corporate activism is a large part of its brand identity. In 2017, the company sued then-President Donald Trump over his administration’s move to dramatically shrink two national monuments in Utah.

Labor & working conditions Confirmed Against

Patagonia faces exploitation claims in supply chain

Patagonia's internal audits found forced labor and human trafficking in its supply chain, as reported by Cara Chacon and Thuy Nguyen.

1 sourceRead sources
business-humanrights.org
Patagonia is an accredited and founding member of the Fair Labor Association...And yet, despite these aspirations, four years ago internal audits turned up multiple instances of human trafficking, forced labor, and exploitation in Patagonia’s supply chain, according to Cara Chacon, the company’s director of social and environmental responsibility, and Thuy Nguyen, the manager of supply chain social responsibility and special programs.

Corporate conduct Recall Against

Patagonia recalls infant base layer sets due to choking hazard

Patagonia recalled Patagonia Infant Capilene Midweight Base Layer Sets because of a choking hazard.

2 sourcesRead sources
srs.dph.illinois.gov
Description This recall involves Patagonia Infant Capilene Midweight Base Layer Sets, sold in sizes 0 months through 24 months with style number 60910.
cpsc.gov

Patagonia Recalls Patagonia Infant Capilene Midweight Base Layer Sets Due to Choking Hazard

Patagonia Recalls Patagonia Infant Capilene Midweight Base Layer Sets Due to Choking Hazard

Corporate conduct Recall Against

Patagonia recalls 3,000 Penguino toys

Patagonia voluntarily recalls 3,000 Patagonia Penguino stuffed penguin toys due to a documented safety risk.

1 sourceRead sources
saferproducts.gov
[{"ConsumerContact":null,"Description":"March 9, 1995 Release # 95-090 Washington, DC - CPSC, Patagonia Inc. of Ventura, Calif., is voluntarily recalling 3,000 of its Patagonia Penguino stuffed penguin toys.

Political spending Confirmed You decide

Patagonia endorses political candidates

Patagonia endorsements political candidates for the first time in its history.

4 sourcesRead sources
qz.com
For the first time in its history, hippie favorite Patagonia is endorsing political candidates
channel3000.com
It’s the first time Patagonia has made political endorsements.
wral.com
It's the first time Patagonia has made political endorsements.
yahoo.com
Patagonia's Official Endorsement of Two Senate Candidates Is a First for the Company

Political spending Allegation You decide

Patagonia is accused of lying about Trump stealing public lands

Patagonia is accused of lying after claiming Trump stole public lands by shrinking Bears Ears and another Utah monument.

1 sourceRead sources
sg.finance.yahoo.com
The company also sparred with Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke, who accused Patagonia of lying after it claimed on its website that Trump "stole" public lands by shrinking Bears Ears and another monument in Utah.

Elections & voting Confirmed You decide

Ryan Gellert said voting access is under threat

Patagonia’s CEO Ryan Gellert said lawmakers in Georgia and other states are making it harder for voters to cast ballots.

1 sourceRead sources
independent.co.uk
Patagonia’s CEO, Ryan Gellert, said on Tuesday “that instead of celebrating democracy in action, a group of lawmakers in Georgia and states across America are doing everything in their power to make it harder for their constituents to vote”.

Labor & working conditions Confirmed Against

CEO Ryan Gellert announces restructuring

CEO Ryan Gellert announces restructuring at Patagonia.

1 sourceRead sources
fastcompany.com
Patagonia layoffs 2024: CEO Ryan Gellert announces restructuring - Fast Company

Community investment Confirmed In favor

Chouinards transfer voting shares to environmental trust

In August 2022, Yvon Chouinard, his wife, and their two children transferred all voting shares of Patagonia to the Patagonia Purpose Trust for environmental philanthropy.

20 sourcesRead sources
dailycaller.com
Patagonia channels all its profits, excluding those reinvested in the company, through an entity named Holdfast Collective, which has established and oversees five different 501(c)(4) nonprofits, according to the NYT.
grist.org
Chouinard, his wife, and their two adult children transferred all of the company’s voting stock, or 2 percent of all shares, to the newly created Patagonia Purpose Trust, as first reported by the New York Times.
jlsp.law.columbia.edu
2 While Patagonia itself would continue to operate as a traditional private for -profit corporation, the Chouinard family transferred all of the company’s voting stock (two percent of total shares) into a new entity called the Patagonia Purpose Trust.3 Close advisors and family members would oversee the trust, which has the decision-making authority to ensure that Patagonia maintains its socially responsible business methods and charitable giving practices.4 The remaining 98% of Patagonia, its common shares, were donated to the Holdfast Collective, a newly established 501(c)(4) nonprofit which will receive all of Patagonia’s profits and use them to fund efforts to combat climate change.5 On Patagonia’s website, the company declared: “Earth is now our only shareholder.”6 Patagonia’s new business structure7 is the latest innovation in the world of “social enterprises,” broadly defined as companies that 1.
According to the initial New York Times article announcing the change, Patagonia itself will continue to operate as a private for-profit public benefit corporation based in Ventura, California.170 All of the company’s voting stock, two percent of total shares, was transferred from the Chouinard family to the newly - established Patagonia Purpose Trust, overseen by “members of the family and their closest advisers.”171 The Patagonia Purpose Trust intends “to ensure that Patagonia makes good on its commitment to run a socially responsible business and give away its profits.”172 The remaining 98% of the shares, the common shares of the company, were donated to the Holdfast Collective, a newly established nonprofit organization that will receive all the company’s profits and use the capital to combat climate change.173 As a 501(c)(4), the Holdfast Collective can also make unlimited political contributions and has distributed over $71 million to more 166.
messaging-custom-newsletters.nytimes.com
Patagonia and the Chouinards set up a series of trusts, limited liability corporations and charitable groups designed to protect the independence of the clothing company while distributing all of its profits through an entity known as the Holdfast Collective.
newrepublic.com
What should we make of Patagonia founder Yvon Chouinard’s decision to transfer ownership of his company to a special trust and nonprofit dedicated to environmental values? It’s hard to say, given that the public hasn’t been given any details on the matter.
observer.com
The family transferred its voting shares, around 2 percent of its stock, to the Patagonia Purpose Trust to protect the company’s values.
observer.com
To date, the collective groups have received $210 million in dividends from Patagonia and deployed roughly $175 million of that capital.
vip-stage.washingtonexaminer.com
On Patagonia’s tax forms filed with the IRS, the private foundation said its grants to AFGJ were “to support environmental projects.” Patagonia’s focus on environmentalism is no anomaly: With the stated aim of combating climate change, Patagonia underwent an unusual corporate restructuring in 2022, as its founder, Yvon Chouinard, and his family transferred their ownership of Patagonia to a trust and nonprofit group.
aspentimes.com
With Chouinard’s blessing, Patagonia’s ownership was transferred to the Holdfast Collective and the Patagonia Purpose Trust.
axios.com
Patagonia was founded by Yvon Chouinard, a lifelong rock climber so uncomfortable with his wealth that he pushed to get himself removed from the Forbes billionaire list.
businessinsider.com
And he got to make sure his pet causes were cared for — much like Chouinard has done with the donation of Patagonia to his own nonprofits that he says will advocate for climate change. It was a huge move, and it instantly lit up the business world.
businessinsider.com
Over the years, Patagonia has pioneered ecological innovations to reduce its carbon footprint, taken activist political stances even at the expense of its bottom line, and given $145 million to environmental causes.
cnbc.com
Patagonia founder Yvon Chouinard, his spouse and two adult children are giving away their ownership in the apparel maker he started some 50 years ago, dedicating all profits from the company to projects and organizations that will protect wild land and biodiversity and fight the climate crisis. The company is worth about $3 billion, according to the New York Times.
cnbc.com
Yvon Chouinard donates Patagonia to fight climate change, protect land
fastcompany.com
Despite this change, Gellert insists that the company’s mission and values remain intact: “Many people have asked me how Patagonia has changed since its founders, the Chouinards, transferred ownership of the company to the Patagonia Purpose Trust and the Holdfast Collective two years ago,” Gellert wrote.
influencewatch.org
The two nonprofits will donate 100 percent of Patagonia’s future profits (roughly $100 million annually as of 2022) to environmentalist efforts.
In 2024, Patagonia transferred approximately $79.8 million in profits to the Holdfast Collective, including $63.3 million to the Holdfast Trust and about $16.5 million to four other affiliated trusts.
Patagonia had previously donated $50 million to Holdfast prior to the sale and another $100 million was donated from Patagonia following the transfer.
In August 2022, Patagonia founder Yvon Chouinard, his wife, and their two children, transferred all voting shares (about 2% of total company shares) of the company to the Patagonia Purpose Trust, a trust overseen by the Chouinards dedicated to using Patagonia’s profits for philanthropic environmental purposes.
insidephilanthropy.com
According to the letter: “100% of the company’s voting stock transfers to the Patagonia Purpose Trust, created to protect the company’s values; and 100% of the nonvoting stock had been given to the Holdfast Collective, a nonprofit dedicated to fighting the environmental crisis and defending nature.
newsweek.com
Addressing CEO Ryan Gellert, the board of directors and the company’s Purpose Trust, Pattie Gonia opened by praising Patagonia as an “exceptional company” with a long-standing commitment to environmental protection.
theguardian.com
“How do we ensure that traditional living and practices that have been going on for the better part of a century or more don’t get disrupted?” said Alex Perry, the Latin America general manager for Patagonia, which has been funding local conservation groups in the Cochamó Valley for more than a decade and in 2024 donated $4m through the company’s non-profit owner, Holdfast Collective.
vcstar.com
Patagonia adopted a new ownership structure in 2022 that involves giving excess profits to a nonprofit.

Health policy Confirmed You decide

Patagonia CEO Ryan Gellert opposes roadless rule rollback

Patagonia CEO Ryan Gellert publicly opposes the Trump administration's proposal to overturn the "Roadless Rule," urging the public to comment before the deadline this Friday.

1 sourceRead sources
yahoo.com
Patagonia CEO Ryan Gellert publicly opposes the Trump administration's proposal to overturn the "Roadless Rule," urging the public to comment before the deadline this Friday.

Climate & energy Settlement Against

Patagonia Building Supplies, Inc., dba as W. Los Angeles Building Materials

In September 2009, Patagonia Building Supplies, Inc., dba as W. Los Angeles Building Materials, agreed to pay $9,000 in penalties; $6,750 to the California Air Pollution Fund, $1,125 to the Peralta Community College District, and $1,125 to the California Pollution Control Financing Authority for violating air quality regulations.

1 sourceRead sources
ww2.arb.ca.gov
In September 2009, Patagonia Building Supplies, Inc., dba as W. Los Angeles Building Materials, agreed to pay $9,000 in penalties; $6,750 to the California Air Pollution Fund, $1,125 to the Peralta Community College District, and $1,125 to the California Pollution Control Financing Authority for violating air quality regulations.